Monday, 14 February 2011

Russian reality

I've mentioned before how Russia is one of the most deeply cynical and corrupt places I've known. Peter Pomerantsev, a British TV producer, spent the last four years in Moscow making programmes for Russian television. From his latest diary entry:
The fundamental premise for most Western reality shows is what people in the industry call ‘aspirational’: someone works hard and is rewarded with a wonderful new life. The shows celebrate the outstanding individual, the bright extrovert. For the Russian version of The Apprentice, Vladimir Potanin, a metals oligarch worth more than $10 billion, was recruited to be the boss choosing between the candidates competing for the dream job. Potanin goaded, teased and tortured the candidates as they went through increasingly difficult challenges. The show looked great, the stories and dramas all worked, but there was a problem: no one in Russia believed in the rules. The usual way to get a job in Russia is not by impressing at an interview, but by what is known as blat – ‘connections’. Russian society isn’t much interested in the hard-working, brilliant young business mind. Everyone knows where that type ends up: in jail like Mikhail Khodorkovsky, or in exile like the mobile phone billionaire Yevgeny Chichvarkin. Today’s Russia rewards the man who operates from the shadows, the grey apparatchik, the master of the politique de couloir – the man like Putin. Promotion in such a system comes from knowing how to debase yourself, how to suck up and serve your master, how to be what the Russians call a holop, a ‘toady’. Bright and extrovert and aspirational? Not if you want success. The shows that did work were based on a quite different set of principles. By far the biggest success was Posledny Geroi (‘The Last Hero’), a version of Survivor, a show based on humiliation and hardship. This chimed in Russia – a country where being bullied by the authorities is the norm.
[...]
What’s Russia’s problem with reality? The basic principle of reality-based programming is that the audience believes the characters are having real experiences, that the action is not predetermined. The producer’s skill lies in nudging and manipulating the heroes into behaving in an interesting way. Russian channel heads refused to countenance the idea that you could make ‘reality’ programmes which weren’t scripted beforehand...

Read the whole thing: there's also some great stuff on the routine extortion of the tax authorities. What a fucked up place.

3 comments:

zmkc said...

Depressing in all regards - except that of the failure of reality TV there, which one can only hope will be a phenomenon that spreads like wildfire throughout the televisual world.

Gaw said...

It's sobering to think that Russian reality is even worse than the reality we see on TV.

Hey Skipper said...

It is going on 20 years since I was there, but the overwhelming impression I have of the place is badness beyond the ability of mere words to describe.